Monday, December 3, 2012

PHEOC Write Up


Problem:
What is the impact of different amounts of water inside a can do to the crushing ability?

Hypothesis:
I believe that the amount of liquid inside the can will affect the crushing ability. My thoughts on my reasoning are; If the liquid inside the can increases the pressure and the volume it will make the cans ability to crushed a little harder. I think the less liquid you have in a can the more the can will be crushed. I believe this because if you have a can filled with little liquid the little amount of liquid is going heat up faster creating that gas in less time. Then when you put the can in cold water there is less hot boiling liquid for it to change degrees and so it has the most crushing ability.

Experimental Design:
Materials
1.      Bunsen Burner
2.      Goggles
3.      Measuring Tube
4.      Metal Pliers
5.      20 Cans (For Multiple Mistakes and Trials)
6.      Bucket (Filled with Cold Water)
7.      An available Sink 

Variables:
CV: Temperature of the Water inside the can, Size of the Can, Time over the Bunsen burner after you've seen the vapor, The Temperature of the water inside the bucket that you dump the can into
IV: The amount of  water inside the can
DV: The volume of the can (Crushed)

Procedure:
In order to properly test my hypothesis, I gathered all of the needed equipment and headed to the Academy Counter Space. First you need to put on your safety goggles, and set up all your materials including your 20 cans, bowl, Bunsen Burner, measuring tube, and pliers. Then you will need to fill the bowl with cold water. After a teacher has connected the Bunsen Burner to the Gas Plug, you are almost ready. Grab the measuring tube and filled it up with 5 milliliters of water(starting water amount) then you will need to grab one of your cans and fill it with the water inside your measuring tube. Next ignite your Bunsen burner grab your pliers and your can. Take your pliers and pick up the can. Now your experiment starts. Hold the can over the flam of the Bunsen Burner so that just the tip of the flame is touching your can. Wait a few minutes until you see water vapor spouting from the top of the can once you see this it is very important that you admittedly count to ten. Once you hit the number 10 you will then tip your can into the bowl of cold water. This part of the experiment needs to be consistent. When you tip your can into the bowl it will need to go straight into the water inside the bowl. After you tip your can into the bowl of water it will be crushed. The volume of your can after its been crushed will depend on the amount of water inside your can at the start of the experiment. You will need to have multiple trials for your experiment. Each water amount (5,15,30,45, and 100 milliliters) will need to have 3 trails. When you have all your data needed after all of the trails have been completed you should record all your data and observations.

Conclusion and Analysis:
 I wanted to test whether or not the amount of liquid inside a can would affect the crushing ability. In my hypothesis I stated that the can would be affected, and with less water inside the can the more crushing ability it would have. With my results my hypothesis was supported. The cans that were filled with 5 milliliters of water held 77 milliliters of water after the experiment ( the cans usually hold 350 milliliters).  As the amount of water inside that can increased the water it held after the experiment would also increase meaning it had less of a damaging crush.

After further research, I figured out the true reason why the can crushes more with less water. It deals with Charles and Boyles Law. When you hold your can over the Bunsen Burner it starts to steam, creating water vapor. When this happens your molecules inside your liquid are spreading apart (Into a Gas). When you tip your can into the cold water the molecules instantly become closer together like a liquid, bringing the can with it. The reason smaller amounts of water create a more damaging crush is because the water has more space in the can for the molecules to spread out when it turns in to a gas.